New York State’s ambitious plan to transition to electric vehicles by 2035 is hitting resistance from local auto dealers who say the mandate is coming too soon and could hurt their businesses. ## The Mandate’s Requirements
The state requires that by the end of this year, 35% of new vehicle sales at local dealerships be electric. This percentage is set to increase annually, reaching 68% by 2030 and 100% by 2035. ## Dealers’ Concerns
Local auto dealers argue that the mandate is out of touch with consumer demand and the current infrastructure. “We are for EV vehicles, we are for cleaner air, but we won’t force our customers to buy something they don’t want to buy,” said Lauren Paddock, executive vice president at Paddock Chevrolet. The dealers are concerned that the mandate will lead to limited availability of gas-powered vehicles, potentially driving customers to make purchases out of state.
“Unfortunately, it means limited availability for gas-powered vehicles. We want people to shop locally, not out of state. If we can’t supply, people may go out of state,” said Jim Basil, vice president of Joe Basil Chevrolet. ## Economic and Infrastructure Challenges
The average price of an electric vehicle is currently $66,000, compared to $50,000 for gas-powered vehicles, although entry-level EVs can be found for under $30,000. Dealers also point out that the infrastructure to support widespread EV adoption is not yet in place. “Just look around. You cannot find an EV charger. Hard to find,” Paddock said.
The New York State Department of Environmental Conservation responded to the dealers’ concerns, stating that the regulation applies to manufacturers, not consumers and dealers, and that various flexibilities within the regulation mean that achieving 35% EV sales is not required. However, local auto dealers and politicians are pushing back, arguing that the mandate will have significant economic impacts on their businesses and communities.
U.S. Rep. Nick Langworthy, a local Republican, has been vocal in his opposition to the mandate and is urging Governor Kathy Hochul to reconsider. “He sees bipartisan support to eliminate the mandate and is urging Governor Hochul to reconsider, and allow for a more gradual transition that reflects local consumer demand,” according to a report by 2 On Your Side.
