Modern vehicles are evolving beyond simple transportation, integrating advanced software and hardware to offer a comprehensive in-car experience. A crucial element of this evolution is connected car technology, with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto leading the charge in in-car infotainment systems. These systems allow users to sync their smartphones with their vehicles, offering access to personal data and preferences while on the road. While Apple CarPlay primarily works with iPhones and Android Auto functions with a majority of Android-powered phones, each system provides drivers with a connected experience.
While both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto aim to provide similar connected experiences, their features and functionalities differ. Each system holds its own advantages and disadvantages. Let’s delve into a comparison of these two technologies.
User Interface
Apple recently updated Apple CarPlay in iOS 18, introducing customization options to the user interface and functionalities. These include a consolidated view of various applications such as music, maps, and Siri suggestions. The iOS 18 update also offers greater flexibility, offering dual screen functionality with a split view allowing a larger visual area.
Android Auto, which received an update earlier in the year, features shortcuts to recently used music, navigation, and phone apps at the bottom of the screen. It includes a ‘Now Playing’ card, enhancing the user experience. Android Auto’s smart features include awareness of frequently used and default applications, such as Spotify or YouTube Music.
Navigation
Android Auto provides users with the ability to pan and explore their route just like they can on their phone. Apple users, while not limited to Apple Maps, may find the navigation less intuitive. Apple CarPlay requires users to use arrow keys to move the map, which can be challenging and potentially dangerous when driving. Android Auto offers the convenience of tapping an alternative route highlighted on the screen for easy rerouting.
Calls and Notifications
With the iOS 18 update, Apple CarPlay has enhanced its notification features. It now offers a notification-silencing option to minimize distractions while driving. The message option now displays the sender’s profile picture. However, Apple CarPlay can be more intrusive with banners appearing at the bottom of the screen, which could obstruct the user’s view of the navigation if needed. Android Auto places banners at the top of the screen, which may be less distracting. Android Auto also gives users the option to dismiss or mute specific notifications.
Voice Commands
Voice assistants and voice commands significantly enhance the in-car experience by facilitating control over the car’s system or the phone’s OS without requiring drivers to handle devices or use the car’s buttons while driving. Both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto support this functionality through Siri and Google Assistant, respectively. Google Assistant often receives acclaim for better understanding requests, and commands, and supports a wider array of third-party services compared to Siri.
Both systems provide impressive functionality, but the ‘best’ choice depends on your needs and preferences.
