Yellow Car Showdown: 2004 VW Beetle vs 2017 Ford Transit Connect
The Autopian’s daily car comparison continues with two unexpected yellow vehicles: a 2004 Volkswagen Beetle GLS and a 2017 Ford Transit Connect. Both are available for purchase on Craigslist, priced at $4,000 and $4,300 respectively.
2004 Volkswagen Beetle GLS – $4,000

The 2004 VW Beetle features a 2.0-liter overhead cam inline 4 engine and a six-speed automatic transmission with Tiptronic manual shift capability. With only 89,000 miles on the odometer, this front-wheel-drive vehicle is said to run and drive well according to the seller in Indianapolis, IN.
The interior is described as clean, with decorative plastic flowers in the vents and seat covers that may be hiding leather or vinyl underneath. The seller claims it’s “well prepared for all kinds of weather,” suggesting the convertible top functions properly.

The pale yellow color suits the Beetle well, showcasing Volkswagen’s variety of color options. However, the choice between this retro-themed convertible and a more practical option like the Golf remains a personal one.
2017 Ford Transit Connect – $4,300

In contrast, the 2017 Ford Transit Connect is a practical choice, previously used as a DHL delivery van. It boasts a 2.5-liter dual overhead cam inline 4 engine and a six-speed automatic transmission, also front-wheel drive. Located in Eden Prairie, MN, this van has accumulated 272,000 miles but is said to still run and drive fine.
The Transit Connect’s history as a commercial vehicle is evident, with the red DHL logos removed from its bright yellow body. It features a bulkhead behind the front seats, which may or may not be desirable depending on the buyer’s needs.

The decision between these two vehicles hinges on the buyer’s priorities: a fun, albeit high-mileage, van or a lower-mileage convertible with character. The community is invited to vote for their preferred vehicle.
Readers’ comments vary, with some praising the Beetle’s lower mileage and others appreciating the Transit Connect’s practicality despite its higher mileage. The discussion highlights the diverse needs and preferences of potential buyers in the used car market.
Which one would you choose? The vintage-style VW Beetle or the practical Ford Transit Connect?